False Identity May Not Mean ID Theft in All Cases

Posted by Melanie Henson on Saturday, December 6th, 2008

If you use a fake identity, are you an identity thief? Lawyers will argue in the Supreme Court early next year (2009) that you may not be…if you didn’t realize the false ID was connected to a real person.

Immigrants and ID

It’s nowhere near as confusing as it sounds…and it’s a lot more commonplace than you’d think. Experts in the case Flores-Figueroa v. United States, which demands a two-year prison sentence for “knowingly” using another person’s identification, point out that purchasing false ID doesn’t mean the individual realizes it already belongs to another person.

In fact, many immigrants to the U.S. seek ID in order to be able to obtain work, experts argue. In doing so, they may assume the entire name itself–and the Social Security number–are entirely made up.

Rethinking the Law

Because the person may not be fully aware that the identification he or she is obtaining already belongs to another individual, Flores-Figueroa v. United States warrants rehashing, lawyers say.

This reasoning caused the Supreme Court to grant a review of Flores-Figueroa on Oct. 20, 2008. The case will be heard in early 2009, according to reports.

A Split Decision

Of course, obtaining and/or utilizing false ID is still a crime, not all of the law is up for reassessment, some circuits of the U.S. Supreme Court have ruled. These were split, with the 1st, 9th and DC circuits ruling that Flores-Figueroa may not apply if the defendant was unaware that he had stolen the ID of an actual person. The 4th, 8th and 11th circuits argued that the law should apply regardless.

The United States requested that the case be heard before the Supreme Court in order to resolve this difference.

What it May Mean

It’s difficult to project what a decision either way would mean to defendants, the people they obtained the ID from and how similar crimes will be prosecuted in the future. However, a revamping of false ID laws could result.

It might also mean harsher penalties for those found to be giving out and/or selling the false identification, as they stole the ID in the first place.

According to anti-crime experts and prosecutors, this could be good news for people concerned with their own identification being stolen and used and would follow the general trend over the past several years in which ID theft is taken more and more seriously.

On the other hand, for immigrants seeking work, the penalties may be similar even if the crimes of obtaining the fake ID and of knowing it is attached to a real individual were separated out.

In the meantime, identity theft continues to remain top on the agenda of many crime professionals who seek to make it more and more difficult for innocent people to become victims of this growing issue. As more related crimes go to the Supreme Court, ID theft may finally begin to receive the recognition–and serious crack-down–it needs.



Filed under Identity Theft

 Subscribe to this site   

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

9 Responses to “False Identity May Not Mean ID Theft in All Cases”

  1. sip trunks Says:

    For the reason that the admin of this web page is working, no hesitation
    very soon it will be renowned, due to its quality contents.

  2. bakkenwatch.com Says:

    Very quickly this site will be famous amid all blogging viewers,
    due to it’s nice articles

    Here is my website :: click here (bakkenwatch.com)

  3. Kimberly Says:

    But, despite all the bumps in the road, I don’t
    regret the path we’ve taken. Kate loped beside me as I made
    my wobbling way down the suburban sidewalk of
    Croftdon Street. While you travel, you can carry it with you even when you
    are riding a bus or a train provided you fold it
    well so as not to bother the other passengers.

  4. solar panels ontario Says:

    in that location are many solar panels ontario miscellanies of solar.
    But the length of service of the panel is quick to instal a solar panel
    market at a price range. The solar tariffs, having got stabilised for higher aces.
    If setting up a peaceful solar applied sciences or companies.

    Hurricane Aluminum Solar Blanket Reel for In-Ground Pools.
    The bargainers solar panels ontario that you–that you function out what solar panels which dual as a simpler installation overall.
    When the sun is a Solar Worcester Bosch FKT-1W.

  5. potty training seats for girls Says:

    Stay cool and positive, and have fun with your child during this trying process.
    But there are three things you can do now, to save your carpets and your sanity.
    It’s best practice to not attempt to train your pet ferret to use one litter box.

    Here is my site; potty training seats for girls

  6. dispatch pest control henderson Says:

    Hmm is anyone else having problems with the pictures on
    this blog loading? I’m trying to find out if its a
    problem on my end or if it’s the blog. Any feed-back would be greatly appreciated.

    Feel free to visit my web page; dispatch pest control henderson

  7. birmingham.cylex-uk.co.uk Says:

    Doors, windows, and cabinetry have become specializations in themselves and have become distinct trades.

    In addition to cutting painting time, there is less set up
    and clean up involved when you don. As a apprentice carpenter, you have the opportunity of
    four years with developing and construction businesses, subcontractors, group teaching organizations, self employment or government departments.

  8. carpenter Birmingham Says:

    c) are supported by credible industry reputation, reliability
    and service. In addition to cutting painting time, there is less
    set up and clean up involved when you don. These craftsmen have the knowledge, tools and time to ensure your home.

  9. how to find best divorce lawyer Says:

    Do you have a spam issue on this blog; I also am a blogger, and I was wanting to know your situation;
    many of us have developed some nice procedures and we are looking to
    swap solutions with others, be sure to shoot me an
    e-mail if interested.

    Feel free to surf to my web page; how to find best divorce lawyer

Leave a Comment

Compare ID Protection



Credit Monitoring Reviews

Identity Theft Tips
ID Theft Ebook Special


Website Resources

Please contact us for more information or questions about this website.

Learn more about us and what this website can do for you.

If you find this site to be of interest, please link to us.

Visit our directory for related websites and services you may be interested in.

Browse our site map for all articles and resources on identity theft.

Please read our privacy policy and terms of use.